Eight-year-old Leilani Rivera was in her second-grade class at Wayside Elementary on May 9 when a volunteer reader came into the classroom with an associate and two dogs.

After the reading was done, the children were allowed by the reader to pet the dogs, and Leilani wanted to participate. As she went in to give one of the dogs a hug, she said, the dog bit her in the face, splitting her bottom lip and cutting her right cheek.

“I was crying. It was really painful,” Leilani said.

Leilani quickly underwent reconstructive surgery to her face at Kern Medical Center. While she is in the process of recovering, she can only be fed liquids through a syringe in her mouth. She is also taking several medications to help with the healing and the pain.

“I broke down in tears,” Leiliani’s aunt, Andrea Gonzalez, said about when she arrived at the hospital and saw the state her niece was in. “I’m still very upset and hurt. She’s been so brave, but it’s been a struggle because she’s in pain every day.”

Now that Leilani has begun the healing process, the law firm Chain Cohn Stiles has filed a claim against the Bakersfield City School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools on behalf of Leilani’s family alleging negligence in allowing the dogs in a classroom.

The claim is seeking coverage of Leilani’s medical bills and other damages, but does not specify a dollar amount except that it is more than $25,000.

“As a parent, you don’t expect when you take your child to school in the morning and drop them off at a place that’s supposed to be safe that they’re going to get bit by a dog. That’s the last expectation,” said attorney Matthew Clark. “Getting bitten by a dog in a second-grade classroom, that simply shouldn’t happen.”

Clark said that to the law firm's knowledge, the dogs that were brought by the volunteer, Ann Ardell — named Fred and Barney — are akitas or chows and should not have been allowed into a classroom due to their propensity for violence.

“Those are two breeds of dogs that are excluded on almost every homeowner’s policy in California because they’re considered a known dangerous breed,” he said. “They’re dangerous enough that (companies) are unwilling to insure that type of dog, so the fact that they were brought into a second-grade classroom and put in close proximity to 8-year-old students is just unacceptable.”

BCSD said in a statement that school officials immediately sought medical aid for Leilani and have begun an investigation into the circumstances of the incident.

“Our hearts go out to the student and family affected by the incident... at Wayside Elementary School. The safety and well-being of our students is our top priority,” the district said. "While the district is not able to discuss the incident that occurred or the investigation, please be assured that we are continuing to prioritize the needs of our students."

The district said it is reaching out to Wayside parents to answer any questions they may have about the attack. Counseling services are also available to students. 

While Clark said Ardell had come to classrooms in the past to read to students as part of KCSOS’ Community Reading Project, this most recent incident was the only time that dogs had been brought in.

KCSOS provided the following statement about the attack:

“First and foremost, our hearts go out to Leilani Rivera and her family for this unfortunate accident. Since 1999, KCSOS has trained Community Reading Project volunteers in guided oral reading strategies so they are prepared to help local second grade students improve their reading skills. Volunteers are then fingerprinted and partnered with participating schools. Due to pending litigation, we are unable to comment further at this time.”

Gonzalez said she hopes the attack will lead BCSD to change its policies about who is let on campus.

“I just want to see a change and make sure this doesn’t happen to any other child,” she said.

Leilani said she’s been resting at home since the attack, but is looking forward to getting better and being able to return to class.

“I want to go back to school. I miss going to school,” she said.

Joseph Luiz can be reached at 395-7368 or by email at jluiz@bakersfield.com. You can also follow him on Twitter @JLuiz_TBC. 

(3) comments


Well amazing. We do know that the two people let on campus had legal problems & more importantly brought (2) two chow breed dogs to the class room. Wow or should I say REALLY? Ahhh but of course then mom is going to sui, though she says she just wants to see change, right! She wants the cold hard cash, lol. Course I don't blame her, my daughter ends up under a surgical knife because of someone's stupidity, yea I probably would do the same if not beat em to death (just kidding, sort of). Um, how bout we do a better job of vetting these folks.


Does being fingerprinted mean that a background check was performed? Maybe more than fingerprinting is necessary. A quick check of the Superior Court of California criminal and civil cases revealed that both Ann Ardell and Jeff Jones, whose name appeared in an earlier news release, are no strangers to either the criminal or civil courts. How did these two people with such a checkered past make it past the vetting process, and more alarmingly make it into a 2nd grade classroom with dogs known for their aggressive behavior? Well taxpayers, get ready to pay for an event that was completely preventable - starting with fingerprinting.


You're making quite an allegation. Checkered past? You want to elaborate on that? You come in with vague accusations and quite frankly Poor knowledge but I will give you this you know how to Google stuff so good for you.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.