California’s looming shortage of college-educated workers has been well-documented, particularly in a series of reports by the Public Policy Institute of California.

PPIC and others point out deficiencies in the state’s K-12 system that prepares too few students for college admission and – more importantly – college success and the physical and organizational shortcomings of the state’s public universities that impede the pathway to graduation.

The reports on the bottlenecks in producing the college graduates California needs to replace retiring baby boomers and drive an ever-changing, technology-heavy economy point to a systemic deficiency.

Although the state’s half-century-old “master plan” for higher education envisioned seamless cooperation by the University of California, the California State University system and dozens of locally governed community colleges, it never really happened.

They often compete for pieces of limited state higher education funds for physical construction and operations, and have often been at odds over the criteria for student transfers from one system to another.

Moreover, the three have jousted in the Capitol over academic turf – the University of California jealously guarding its power to award doctorates against efforts by CSU to expand post-graduate courses, and CSU resisting the ambitions of community colleges to award four-year baccalaureate degrees.

The latter rivalry has been especially nettlesome because it has prevented students who cannot, for economic or familial reasons, attend a four-year college, from achieving the educations they seek and we need.

Many of the state’s 100-plus community colleges stand ready to offer four-year degrees but they have been restricted to a pilot program that allows a very few schools to offer baccalaureate programs in a very few obscure fields that CSU deigns to ignore.

Community college-based four-year degrees are common in many other states, but in California, CSU has stoutly resisted efforts to expand the notion.

This week, the Legislature’s budget analyst, Mac Taylor, issued an “interim evaluation” of the pilot program that was inconclusive.

It said that allowing community colleges to offer degrees in a few fields appears to be expanding access to students who would otherwise not be able to seek them, but that the fields themselves are often those that may not require bachelor’s degrees to pursue.

Basically, it concluded that more experience is needed to have data that would prove whether expansion of the pilot program is warranted.

That’s not unreasonable, but it becomes a cart-and-horse situation. The issues that Taylor’s report raises are largely caused by the restrictions and uncertainty imposed by the Legislature as it grudgingly allow community colleges to experiment.

Thus, we cannot evaluate allowing community colleges to offer four-year degrees unless, in fact, they are able to do so without those tight restrictions.

The potential to expand access to and graduation from baccalaureate programs is obvious; it works in other states and there’s no inherent reason why it couldn’t work in California.

But it will work only if the community colleges are freer to expand their degree fields and encouraged to add the facilities and staff that would make the programs attractive to students.

This is no small matter. Realistically, if California is to close the looming shortage of college-educated workers, community colleges must be part of the solution.

Dan Walters writes for CALmatters, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California’s policies and politics. The opinions expressed are his own.

(3) comments


I heard Community college is a 2 year learning program. A few understudies go to junior college on the off chance that they don't have the vital evaluations or test scores for a four year school. I have to Buy Research Paper Online because I heard some go to on the grounds that it doesn't cost as much as a four year school. You get school credits in junior college.


Great article, Dan! Many students seem hardly prepared for community college let alone the UC and CSU systems. But, this is about money, and K-12 children have suffered at the hands of California's liberal policies and greed for many years. The more California's institutions protect their sacred turf, the more likely serious students will figure out a way to get educated. Like many businesses and private citizens, they'll simply tire of the bureaucracy and leave the state.Their dollars will go to online schools and out-of-state programs (as did mine). They'll spend more, but the end-result (as in employability) will be virtually identical with the added bonus of having not contributed to tenure, inflated salaries, and a fair amount of ridiculous bias with lack of understanding of how the real-world operates. Thus, community college undergrad programs are absolutely needed. We might also find that competition drives down costs in the CSU and UC systems.


If you are really serious about the “shortage of college-educated workers” there is a simple solution, start enforcing the immigration laws. The vast majority of illegal aliens in California are not the “brightest and best educated” arriving from their native country. They arrive with very little formal education and to think by enrolling those individuals in the California Educational System will prepare them for college isn’t based in reality. The “brain drain” will continue in California, with a shrinking middle class as well as the overall level of education for those living here. ‘

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.