Reader: The news media does an excellent job reporting the names of arrestees and their crimes. Why not report their immigration status also? This would provide factual information instead of emotional bias to help develop common immigration reform. Just kidding — that wouldn't be politically correct.

— Tom Specht

Price: We might consider including immigration status in our public safety reports, in cases where it has relevance, if we knew what that status was. But immigration status is not reported to us by law enforcement, and for good reason: Local police are not compelled to confirm it or include it in arrest reports, and therefore they don't. They don't know, so we don't know, so you the reader don't know.

Noted Sgt. Brian Holcombe of the Bakersfield Police Department, "We do not have a way to record someone’s immigration status in our records management system."

Other things that may or may not have relevance at the scene of an arrest or later in a criminal court but are not included in police reports, either, might include exposure to communicable diseases, significant health issues, known allergies and addictions, foreign language fluency, marital status, educational attainment and credit score. Nobody asks about that stuff either.

Back to immigration status. Two recent studies, one by the libertarian Cato Institute and one in the journal Criminology, report that undocumented immigrants are less likely than native born residents to commit crimes. I know, I know, not what you want to hear.


Reader: If I am not mistaken, this doctor's name, Dr. Justin Lee, M.D., is incorrectly noted in Dignity Health's ad on Page 5 of your Oct. 26 issue.

I believe if you use "Dr.," then "M.D." is not appropriate. Alternatively if you use "M.D.," then "Dr." is omitted. I learned to never use both.

I love the paper as always. I am not ashamed to tell you that my family and friends have nicknamed me Grammar Queen.

— Molly McKean Sabat

Price: You're correct, Molly, but to me different rules apply when it comes to advertisements. Yes, advertisers are bound by the rules of spelling and grammar, or should be, but I see this as a matter of clarity and emphasis. Justin Lee is a doctor, so let's get the "Dr." right out in front to establish his most essential credentials. Then we ought to know what kind of doctor he is — an "M.D.," for doctor of medicine, as opposed to a dentist or veterinarian.

It's our policy, based on Associated Press style, to put the designation "Dr." only in front of medical doctors and a select few others such as veterinarians and dentists. Dr. Lee, of course, qualifies. But in a news article we would leave out the "M.D." and simply explain, if it were necessary, that he specializes in female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery.

By the way, welcome to Bakersfield, Dr. Lee. We greet all newcomers this way.


Reader: This week it was reported on NPR that President Trump’s false statements have increased from two per day last year to 4.5 per day now. Would it be helpful if TBC published a sidebar quoting the lies and unpacking them?

False statements have no constructive value but serve only to damage the credibility of our nation’s leadership. The president needs to be held accountable for what he says.

— Stephen A. Montgomery

Price: Evaluating the truthfulness of the president's statements is a full-time job, and we just don't have the resources for it. Besides, we focus almost exclusively on local news.

But plenty of fact-checking websites are out there, including FactCheck.org, which is managed by the Annenberg Public Policy Center; PolitiFact, run by the Poynter Institute; and The Washington Post's Fact Checker. I use them all, and often more than one when I'm researching an issue. But then I'm a nerd in that way.


Reader: I have to ask all of you Trump haters and by extension American Constitution haters, what is your plan after you help the world invade this country? ("Migrant caravan pauses to honor dead man, rest, still far from US," Oct. 24.) After the USA is destroyed, then what? Where is your utopia then? After millions more illegals have crashed the border, emptied the treasury and blown up the Constitution, then what is your dream? You apparently want us lawless along with being broke like the rest of the world.

Guess it will be the start of a new dark age. Every human for themselves, as the PC police would say.

— Mike Ladd

Price: Interesting you would ascribe the philosophy of "every human for themselves" to the "PC police," aka, I would assume, liberals. Ayn Rand, poster child of laissez faire capitalism and darling of the 20th-century conservative movement, is commonly associated with an "every man for himself" worldview.

Writes Rand, in "The Romantic Manifesto": "No one, therefore, can claim the objective superiority of his choices over the choices of others. Where no objective proof is available, it’s every man for himself — and only for himself."

For what that's worth.


Reader: Regarding the Oct. 24 article, "Congressman McCarthy's office burglarized": Probably a certain senior editor down at The Californian.

— Gary Johns

Price: I can explain. Just give me a little time to come up with something.

The Californian's Robert Price answers your questions and takes your complaints about our news coverage in this weekly feedback forum. Questions may be edited for space and clarity. To offer your input by phone, call 395-7649 and leave your comments in a voicemail message or email us at soundoff@bakersfield.com. Include your name and phone number; they won’t be published.

(8) comments

Muhammad Fatwa al Jihad

Gary Lowe, how have you determined voter registration? Gary Johns, you are consistently attracted to fecal comments.

Gary Lowe

You going on a "Democratic Rant" against the republicans is not
changing the fact that the democrats in this area
have the highest crime rate in Bakersfield and its coming
from Hispanics, Mexicans, and Immigrants no matter what label you
disguise it with. You people want special rights but you cause the most
crime.

byebyeCA

America, soon to be another 3rd world socialist country. So proud I lived in once was a great America.

Vavoom

during 2016 campaign trail: "drain the swamp"
during presidency trump added to the swamp and maintained it: miller, bannon, lewondowski, pruitt....

Vavoom

trump before president: i will eliminate the debt in 8 years
trump 14-month presidency: raised the debt by 2 trillion

satan mitch McConnell with his tax subsidized healthcare and $193,400 salary said recently programs such as Social Security need to be cut to help make up for the Trump administration’s $779 billion budget deficit, the highest mark for that figure in six years.

Vavoom

trump on dr ford's testimony during beer kavanaugh's fake confirmation hearing: "I thought her testimony was very compelling and she looks like a very fine woman to me, very fine woman. She was very good in many respects... certainly a very credible witness." ~ Donald J. Trump
at a missippi rally several days later mocked her testimony.

Vavoom

trump: "I never met Putin,”
Donald Trump - News conference, July 27, 2016
"I have nothing to do with Russia. I don’t have any jobs in Russia. I’m all over the world but we’re not involved in Russia.”
Donald Trump - CBS interview, 27 July 2016
“we do a lot of business with the Russians” "I met him [Putin] once."
Donald Trump - David Letterman Show, 2013

GaryJohns

Is your colostomy bag full again? You seem to be a little upset….

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.