Doc Ervin

Bakersfield City School District Superintendent "Doc" Ervin is defending the district's decision to cancel 2019 summer school.

Last Dec. 20, the Bakersfield City School District sent a letter to its teachers letting them know that summer school for the 2019 school year was being canceled.

The letter cited "anticipated budget reductions, " "increased costs in summer school programs" and "declining student enrollment in summer school." It also pointed to "the lack of evidence of knowledge retained from the short learning program."

The decision did not sit well with some.

"We think BCSD has an obligation to its most vulnerable student population, which includes foster kids, English language learners and those in poverty," said Cecilia Castro, Education Policy Director with the Dolores Huerta Foundation.

Last year summer school lasted just 13 days at a budgeted cost of $2.7 million. According to district figures, 5,300 students enrolled, but on day one just 3,300 showed up for school and at the end of the session fewer than 3,000 children were in class. This year's budgeted cost is $1.6 million.

At first glance, it might not seem prudent (as George H. W. Bush used to say) to continue on this course. But whoa! Not so fast, several critics say.

"Because it's an LCAP (Local Control and Accountability Plan) goal, they really should have had stakeholder meetings before they chose to discontinue summer school," said Steve Comstock, president of Bakersfield Elementary Teachers Association.

LCAP is a three-year school funding law that gives parents a say in how schools tailor state funds to meet their particular needs. It requires school districts to involve parents in planning and decision-making as well as in developing Local Control and Accountability Plans before any such plan is approved by a school district and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools office.

We're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars here where priority is to be given to help the neediest children including, in particular, foster youth, children eligible for free or reduced price meals, and English language learners.

Under state rules, before adopting an LCAP plan a school district must hold a series of public meetings with stakeholders, meaning parents and advisory groups, to present the plan and to get public input and comment. In this case, BCSD would then adopt the plan in June and forward it to the Kern County Superintendent of Schools office for approval.

Now, here's where critics say BCSD jumped the gun.

If a district wants to amend its LCAP plan in midstream, they must abide by state education code 52062, which states the following: "A governing board of a school district may only adopt a revision to a local control and accountability plan if it follows the process to adopt a local control and accountability plan pursuant to this section and the revisions are adopted in a public meeting."

In this case, BCSD administration, with the blessing of its five school board, announced the decision to amend its plan on Dec. 20, 2018, apparently without first having gone through the proper requirements.

"It seems to us that someone in the district said, 'OK, let's not have summer school, and that's it,' without any of those processes taking place," said Valentin Narvaez, of Greater Bakersfield Legal Assistance. "As far as I can tell, there's been no formal procedure to actually revise the plan that was signed off by the district."

I caught up with BCSD Superintendent "Doc" Ervin at an LCAP symposium held on Saturday at Stiern Middle School to try to clarify the apparent conflict.

"I don't do media interviews," Ervin said as he walked to a classroom for a breakout session.

Ervin said he was done talking about summer school. "There's always individuals out there that are mad or complaining," he added.

He later (sort of) relented and took my questions in a question and answer session in a classroom.

Ervin said the district should've informed parents earlier that it was cutting summer school. "It got away from us when the letter was leaked to the media," said Ervin, adding that the district is now following protocol in informing parents about its December decision.

Ervin said he apologized to a parents' group for not informing them earlier. "If we get 30,000 parents who say, 'We want summer school,' then yeah, we'll revisit it."

Assistant District Superintendent Mark Luque said the district sent its letter out in December, providing plenty of notice to faculty and staff.

The $1.6 million budgeted for summer school this year will go back into the general fund and used for other purposes, said Ervin.

Despite the Ed Code stipulation, it appears BCSD may not have violated any law. "Education code says that a (school district) can make the changes requested without having to repeat all the steps," Robert Meszaros, Kern County Superintendent of Schools spokesman, wrote me in an email. "It would be best practice that districts share any potential changes at board meetings, stakeholder meetings, and/or LCAP advisory meetings," added Meszaros.

The question remains, what to do about declining student enrollment in summer school? BCSD has tried to entice students to come to its summer session by making it seem fun, even offering prizes to those who show up the first week of summer school. Sadly, students who need it the most fail to take advantage.

BCSD will be reevaluating summer program, but no decision has yet been made on whether it will be back next school year.

(7) comments

Fram Smith

I know of no study that shows that having a 10 week break in a child's education, helps them keep the skills they have learned- but that is what the Superintendent of BCSD contains. Ok, lets just take that at face value. With some of the poorest performing students in the state, not budgeting for summer school for students who are far below grade level defies all logic. We claim to be a community that cares about children and the most disadvantaged in our city. It would appear to many that we are a community that doesn't value education.;at least , the education of some.


Hey, were the 699th ranked school district in California. Top 700 baby!


BCSD has 88% of its schools below grade level in ELA. There are 30,000 kids in the district, so that’s 26,400 of them that cannot read and write at grade level. That alone is enough reason for BCSD to provide summer school. Four schools are also on California’s list of lowest performing schools in the state: Emerson, Longfellow, Stella Hills, and Casa Loma. The money for summer school is allocated in the $427,000,000 LCAP budget. And the Superintendent and his cabinet all got raises this school year. The community has every right to ask, “Where is the money going?” Is the Superintendent Mr. Ervin looking out for his best interests or the children’s best interests?


Sounds like Jose Gaspar has flipped over a rock here and found a public official who, "doesn't do interviews". Say what?


If a domestic terrorist group such as the Delores Huerta Foundation wants summer school then BCSD made the right decision


If the Dolores Huerta Foundation wants summer school, then it should step up and provide it. No school district is required to have summer school, except for those students who have an Individualized Education Plan that says they will attend summer school (in that case, the district is legally obligated to provide it.) The Dolores Huerta Foundation thinks that by “insisting” on summer school, money will miraculously appear in the school district’s budget to cover it. That’s not how life works. If The Dolores Huerta Foundation can figure out a way to pay for summer school, they should do so. If not, they have no right demanding that someone else pays for it.


Well said!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.