LOS ANGELES — A new version of Los Angeles’ earthquake early warning app will now alert users of weaker shaking, Mayor Eric Garcetti announced Wednesday.

The change comes after many Angelenos were upset they didn’t receive notice before shaking arrived in L.A. from two powerful quakes 125 miles north of Los Angeles on July 4 and 5.

The new threshold will trigger alerts on the city-owned ShakeAlertLA app when “weak” shaking is forecast to arrive in Los Angeles County — a level of shaking, according to the Modified Mercalli Intensity Scale, that is felt quite noticeably by people inside, especially on upper floors of buildings, but may not be felt by other people, especially those outside.

When the Ridgecrest quakes occurred, the minimum level of shaking that would have triggered a public alert for app users was “light” shaking, a stronger level that can rattle dishes and windows and feel like a heavy truck striking a building.

But the city’s app did not send an alert because the U.S. Geological Survey’s ShakeAlert system forecast only “weak” shaking to arrive in L.A. The forecast was slightly off; in fact, “light” shaking was felt across much of Los Angeles.

Scientists familiar with the system thought the earthquake early warning system performed well; they pointed out that, generally speaking, the system was designed to sound an alarm only before shaking arrived with such an intensity that it could produce damage. The Los Angeles area had almost no reports of significant damage from the July 4-5 quakes.

But experts have concluded that the public would be better served by also receiving warnings to prepare for shaking that, while not damaging, can still be pretty scary.

“People want lower threshold alerts — I think that is loud and clear in terms of what we’re hearing from people,” Berkeley Seismology Lab director Richard Allen told a webinar held by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine last month. “They don’t just want warnings for damaging earthquakes. They want warnings for experienced earthquakes.”

A lower threshold could have given Angelenos perhaps more than half a minute of warning that the shaking was on its way. While the city’s ShakeAlertLA app remained silent, the USGS’ backbone computer earthquake early warning network, ShakeAlert, did detect the July 5 earthquake about 49 seconds before the strongest shaking waves arrived at Los Angeles City Hall.

“People expect to get a warning if they’re going to experience the earthquake, i.e. … they’re going to feel significant shaking,” Allen added.

Another lesson researchers learned is that it’s better to over-alert than to under-alert.

“That’s part of a sort of generational change that is going on right now,” Allen said. “People would rather have more information than less information, and be able to decide what to do with it.”

Scientists have cautioned that the earthquake early warning system in California and the rest of the West Coast will certainly have errors, such as false alarms and missed alerts.

But researchers, as well as residents of other countries such as Mexico and Japan with active early warning systems, say the false alarms and missed warnings are worth the trouble. Successful warnings can save significant numbers of lives by giving people precious seconds to prepare — such as by dropping, covering and holding on — before shaking arrives.

The U.S. West Coast earthquake early warning system is still being tested and is available only for widespread public use through the ShakeAlertLA smartphone app on the iOS and Android systems for users physically in Los Angeles County when an earthquake strikes.

Officials say they still need to install many more earthquake sensors in Washington, Oregon and rural parts of California. And they are working on ways to release alerts more broadly, such as through text messaging and television.


The intensity of shaking from the Ridgecrest quakes was much worse in areas closer to the quakes’ epicenter.

The largest of the quakes, a magnitude 7.1 that hit around 8:10 p.m. July 5, produced “violent” shaking at the sparsely populated epicenter and “strong,” “very strong” or “severe” shaking in the nearby towns of Ridgecrest and Trona.

The twin quakes caused significant damage to Naval Air Weapons Station China Lake; the Navy Times on Monday reported that billions of dollars in repairs might be needed. Trona saw its main economic engine, the Searles Valley Minerals plant, shut down and dozens of homes declared too dangerous to inhabit; Ridgecrest saw some mobile homes torn off foundations and the roof at one movie theater collapse.


©2019 Los Angeles Times

Visit the Los Angeles Times at www.latimes.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


PHOTO (for help with images, contact 312-222-4194): LA-EARTHQUAKES-APP

Copyright 2019 Tribune Content Agency.

(2) comments


EQ alerts, are just another CA boondoggle, we need to put the "EQ scientist" on the bullet train to nowhere and launch it. Even IF IT Worked, you'd not have enough time to to kiss your A$$ goodby.

Sandy Bender

I would like to have enough time to get in a doorway or under a table. It could make the difference between life and death.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.