Another in a series of columns answering consumers’ questions about California’s changing medical landscape.
Martin Estacio was shelling out $800 per month for a health plan that didn’t fit his two-state lifestyle.
The retired San Bernardino firefighter lives between Oklahoma and California. But his health insurance policy, purchased in Oklahoma, didn’t cover non-emergency care outside the state.
So Estacio dropped his plan this month and took a leap of faith. He joined Christian Healthcare Ministries (CHM), an alternative to health insurance that offers a religious approach to covering medical bills.
Health care ministries such as CHM are essentially cost-sharing programs. Members’ monthly fees are applied directly to other members’ medical bills, no matter where they live in the U.S. Members also pray for each other, and often send notes of support and encouragement.
“What led me to look into it was financial,” says Estacio, 58. “When I started to realize it’s based on biblical principles where you help your brother out, that’s what really clinched me.”
A health sharing ministry is primarily a “community of faith,” says Michael Gardner, spokesman for Christian Care Ministry, which operates the Medi-Share program. Medi-Share has roughly 300,000 members as of June, he says.
But let’s be clear: Christian health care ministries are not insurance. You must attend church regularly. You must agree to abstain from certain behaviors, such as “sexual immorality” and drug abuse. Preventive care, routine prescriptions and mental health care may not be reimbursed. Forget about abortion. Coverage for your pre-existing conditions will likely be limited – at least initially.
Estacio pays $150 per month for his membership, plus quarterly payments of about $30 that offer him a higher level of reimbursement.
He’s responsible for the first $500 on each medical incident before the ministry’s sharing kicks in, but only for allowed services. CHM’s list of non-covered services includes “psychological treatment,” medical supplies and equipment, immunizations, maintenance prescriptions, and bills related to drug abuse.
“You have to try to live a good lifestyle,” Estacio says. “You can’t be drinking and smoking. It’s on you.”
Membership in health care sharing ministries has ballooned since passage of Obamacare, in part because the health law provides an exemption for members. If you belong to a qualified health care sharing ministry, you don’t have to pay the Obamacare tax penalty for not having insurance.
About 1 million Americans participate nationwide, according to the Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. Texas has the most members; California places second.
There are more than 100 ministries across the U.S., though the vast majority are small Mennonite churches, says alliance President Dave Weldon, a doctor and former Florida congressman. The three largest ministries are CHM, Medi-Share and Samaritan Ministries International, he says.
All the ministries are Christian at this point, though Weldon says there’s an attempt to start a Jewish sharing ministry.
“It’s our Christian practice of how we bear one another’s burdens,” says James Lansberry, executive vice president of Samaritan Ministries, which has about 227,000 members nationwide.
Samaritan members, who share about $23 million a month, mail their monthly fees directly to other members facing medical bills, along with notes of support, Lansberry says.
Each ministry works differently, but you can generally expect to pay a monthly membership fee. You may be responsible for all of your own routine and preventive medical costs in addition to paying a set amount before reimbursements kick in.
“In effect, they become sort of like catastrophic programs,” Weldon says. “But that’s true for a lot of plans on the Obamacare exchanges as well.”
Unlike catastrophic insurance plans, there’s no contract with health care sharing ministries, he says. That means there’s no guarantee that your bills will be covered.
“However, most of them have always paid their members when they have medical bills,” Weldon says.
Because there’s no guarantee, and because the ministries limit coverage, Sabrina Corlette has two words for you: “Buyer beware.”
“Read the fine print,” says Corlette, research professor at Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms. “Make sure you truly understand what you’re getting with these plans.”
COVERAGE CAPS AND COVERED SERVICES
Some of these ministries put dollar limits on coverage, a practice that Obamacare ended for most commercial health plans.
“If you’re fairly young and fairly healthy, you may never face that,” says Janet Coffman, associate professor of health policy at University of California-San Francisco. But “some people have catastrophic illnesses that may cost millions of dollars.”
Most health sharing ministries don’t cover preventive care such as mammograms, colonoscopies and birth control, and some don’t cover mental health care, addiction treatment and other services, Coffman says.
Since monthly fees are generally less than health insurance premiums, members can save money on those costs, says Medi-Share’s Gardner.
“Because it’s so much less expensive, I can be a good steward of my finances and set some money aside,” he says.
Health care sharing ministries aren’t required to cover pre-existing conditions.
As a result, “a lot of these plans have waiting periods or limitations” on them, says Coffman.
You may have to wait one to three years – or longer – to be reimbursed for pre-existing conditions. And you may face a limit on reimbursement.
PROVIDERS AND CASH PAY
Medi-Share has a network of providers with which it has negotiated rates, though members are not limited to it, Gardner says.
Samaritan does not have such a network.
“Patients are treated by providers as cash pay,” Lansberry says. “Members make their own choice.”
In these cases, if you have a doctor you want to keep, would she be willing to see you as a cash customer?
“We’ve never had trouble with members losing their doctors,” Lansberry says. “Doctors are almost always willing to take cash.”
But remember: you may have to cover the entire cost of the bill and wait for reimbursement.
“Should you have to be hospitalized, could you afford it up front?” Corlette asks.
The ministries encourage you to negotiate for lower prices with providers, though they usually go to the bargaining table for you when the bills are large.
Health sharing ministries are not regulated by the government agencies that oversee commercial health insurance.
If you don’t agree with how much you’re being reimbursed – or whether you’re being reimbursed at all – your only recourse will likely be an internal appeals process.
State regulatory agencies wouldn’t have any power to help you, says Janice Rocco, deputy insurance commissioner at the California Department of Insurance.
We “encourage people to obtain commercial health insurance, which they know they can count on if they have a serious health crisis in the future,” she says.
Estacio hasn’t had to request reimbursement from his health care ministry yet, and he has money set aside for health care expenses that wouldn’t be eligible for reimbursement.
But he’s not worried.
“I’m confident,” he says. “I have faith in it.”
Questions for Emily: AskEmily@kff.org