PARIS –– The French government defended its anti-terrorism measures over the weekend after it turned out that the perpetrator of a deadly knife attack in Paris was on a state security watchlist.

Government spokesman Benjamin Griveaux said the man, a naturalized French citizen who was born in Chechnya in 1997, had been on the watchlist since 2016.

It was the second deadly attack in two months by a person flagged on the watchlist, and the conservative opposition renewed calls for people on the list to be detained or deported.

Griveaux said security forces had foiled 22 attacks over the past 15 months.

“When we live through a tragedy like yesterday, it is visible,” Griveaux told broadcasters LCI and RTL. “What’s unfortunate is that our successes, by definition, are invisible.”

The attack was claimed by Islamic State. French authorities have not confirmed any link with the organization but are treating the incident as a terrorist attack.

A video emerged Sunday online purporting to show the attacker swearing allegiance to Islamic State leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.

In the video, the speaker, wearing a mask that covers most of his face, calls on “my brothers the mujahedeen” in French with scattered Arabic phrases.

In terms typical of Islamic State’s propaganda, he calls on Muslims in Europe to try to move to the group’s now much-reduced territory, or, failing that, to commit attacks at home.

The video, which appeared to have been published by Islamic State’s news agency, Amaq, could not be verified.

The attack near the Paris Opera Saturday night killed a 29-year-old man. Four other people were injured, two of them seriously.

The attacker was shot dead by police, who arrived on the scene within minutes.

Both seriously injured people were out of danger by midday Sunday, a source close to the investigation said.

The attack took place in a busy area with several theaters and many bars and restaurants.

“It is, once again, a way of life, our way of life, which has come under a cowardly attack,” Griveaux said.

The attacker’s parents and a friend were detained for questioning, according to a judicial source.

The revelation that the perpetrator was on the state security watchlist — known as the “S file” — drew an angry reaction from the right and far-right opposition.

In March, a man on the watchlist killed four people in a series of attacks in southern France, including a senior police officer who surrendered to him in return for the freeing of a civilian hostage.

The leader of France’s biggest opposition party renewed his call on President Emmanuel Macron to detain “the most dangerous individuals” on the watchlist and expel all foreigners listed on it.

“There is no longer room, Mr. President, for this blind inaction which has lasted too long,” Laurent Wauquiez of the conservatives Les Republicains said in a statement.

“What use can this S file be if we don’t use it to ensure that these time bombs cannot do any harm on French soil?” National Front leader Marine Le Pen wrote on Twitter.

But Griveaux argued: “Unfortunately, there is no way of stopping this sort of incident from happening.”

The security watchlist was a key tool for police and intelligence services, he said, arguing that experts were opposed to using it as a basis for roundups or deportations.

“If you lock them up then, again, you won’t be able to tease out their networks and dismantle operations that could take place tomorrow,” Griveaux said.


©2018 Deutsche Presse-Agentur GmbH (Hamburg, Germany)

Visit Deutsche Presse-Agentur GmbH (Hamburg, Germany) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


PHOTO (for help with images, contact 312-222-4194): PARIS-ATTACK


Topics: t000402642,t000040457,t000003763

Copyright 2018 Tribune Content Agency.

(8) comments

The Doctor Who Cures Cancer

If the French gov't doesn't want to deport everyone who is on a watchlist, perhaps they could institute a policy where every family member gets deported if their relative commits a terrorist act. Moms, dads, siblings, children, uncles, aunts, nieces and nephews. Children without adequate guardians could become wards of the state.

It might sound harsh, but they are all guests. The policy would send a strong familial message and those family members could apply pressure including turning their relatives in if they are privy to terrorist plans.


The article should read '29 year old man that has been on the watch list since he was 10 years old stabs people in the name of Islam' This should warn all of us of the up bringing and indoctrination of Islam!!!


When will the French people have enough of these evil savages and demand that all followers of Islam the cult, be deported out of the country. Your government is killing you all and allowing these monster to kill you all. You must stand up for yourselves and demand the eradication of all Muslims, and vote in new people to office who are not liberal leaders you have today, who don't care about you!


Griveaux told broadcasters LCI and RTL. “What’s unfortunate is that our successes, by definition, are invisible.” Why do they have to be invisible? Why is the government more concerned about the feelings of Muslims over its own people? This political correctness has gone too far and must stop!


Sad. Fecklessness. You have a guy in your sites. He plans an attack. He must have made plans. There had to be signs -- phone calls, emails. But they missed it. And fight terror by WATCHING terrorists instead of arresting them and interrogating them? The French here are only promulgating the stereotype of French fecklessness. But I must ask... how much of a mere stereotype is it?


Islam demands that allegiance can be only to Allah.

Eagle in NYC

Today France officially re-named its domestic security agency, the "Department of There's a Clean-Up On Aisle Five."

Q: How do you know when France is serious about its security?
A: When it begs for the American army to save it. Again.

Eagle in NYC

Today France officially re-named its domestic security agency, the "Department of Clean-Up On Aisle Five."

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.